WALDORF, Md. (WUSA9) -- "The rings and the band, and the earrings, I mean, pretty much everything. I'm just a jewelry person," says Laura Randolph.
So that made it easy for her husband, Kevin, to know just what to get his bride for Christmas.
"I've never seen anything like it. It was just so pretty," she says.
"She loved it. There was nothing wrong with the ring," says Kevin Randolph.
Until they got the authenticity certificate for her chocolate diamond ring in the mail.
Kevin says, "The ring that I purchased was not what I purchased, apparently."
Allow us to explain: last year, on Black Friday, Kevin says he went into the Jared Jewelers store in Waldorf looking for the perfect gift for Laura.
He settled on a $3,300 1.5-carat chocolate diamond ring made by Levian. It's noted on his receipt.